Name A name for you to identify the wallet. While the development of the MultiSig wallet is ongoing, we will release a standalone alpha version of the wallet as an electron app next week and give a detailed overview of its features. Daily Limit (ETH) A limit which could be withdrawn without the need of required confirmations as configured in point 2. A good estimate could be found on https://ethgasstation.info/. At last, we conclude that: We reported the issue to Gnosis bug bounty program. As part of the project, the team behind Gnosis created Gnosis Safe to secure funds for multiple participants. This ensures that no funds are misused by a person. SHA256(multisigweb_1.4.0_amd64.deb.zip) = 079d43dc095403b4926aaaf9bd2ac4e4627d1827299a6e04367bbdf50f57c401 A wallet with only a seed phrase to access it makes it extremely possible for an employee to go rogue and siphon funds. app, and then unfold the 'Create new payments' permission. Any regular user wouldve hit Confirm right away without even clicking the Data tab. Via the executeCall function of the attached module, anyone can execute actions from the wallet. app, click on the address under (in this case) 'FINANCE', and copy the address: Paste the address in the 'Contract address' field back in the Gnosis Safe: If the 'ABI' field automatically populates, all the contents in the field, since we will need a different ABI, Now we need to get the ABI of the base contract of the app we interact with, which is the. However, any sort of integration that somehow assumes that a Gnosis Safe Multisig wallet is always controlled by its owners will be deeply flawed. Click on the Copy symbol, to copy the ABI of the smart contract: Paste the ABI in the 'ABI' field in the Gnosis Safe, and click on 'Method': Search here for 'newImmediatePayment', since we want to do an immediate payment in this example, and select it: Now find the 'token address' of the token you want to send. Safe is the most trusted decentralized custody protocol and collective asset management platform on Ethereum and the EVM, Previously called Gnosis Safe, Safe spun out with a mission to build a better standard for ownership with smart contract accounts. One important thing is that you can create wallets with any n-of-m schema there. (855) 925-8227 Email Us 3811 Tayrien Court SW Los Lunas, NM 87031 Get Directions. As Ethereum grows and matures, more and more projects will continue integrating Gnosis Safe Multisig wallets, given their popularity and outstanding flexibility. If it is taking too long, or if youre unsure of what your transaction status is, you can always check your address for the transaction on https://etherscan.io (or in this case, on rinkeby.etherscan.io) . Gnosis Safe is an amazing innovation that sets the standard for safer, more honest blockchain applications. Gnosis Safe is the latest release of the Gnosis Multisig Wallets. Click on the vote: Click here on 'Create transaction' and confirm the transaction that should pop-up in your Web3 Wallet: In our example it confirmed that the vote has passed: More DAO members might need to approve the vote for the vote to pass. An incredible $107 billion in assets were stored in Gnosis Safes as of February 2022. Your situation may be different. This implementation does not allow the creation of smart contracts via multisignature transactions. 01 Mar 2023 15:04:06 All contracts are WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. and on our own Shariah-compliant chain, Haqq. This page will help you find one that fits your needs based on the features you want. In this case we will send the DAO Contributor an amount of 0.1 ETH. This is usually done from the Finance app of the DAO, so select 'Finance' here and then click on 'Select an entity': Since we need to add the address of your MultiSig, click here on 'Custom address': Now go to your Gnosis Safe, copy its address and paste the address of your MultiSig in the 'GRANT PERMISSION TO' box. This is exciting for us at Multis because we believe that decentralization through web3 and crypto currencies can unleash a wave of global entrepreneurship. Click on Ethereum Node dropdown menu and select Custom configuration, this would make the Ethereum node's field editable. But in the meantime, do not be afraid to experiment or play around, and youll find deploying a multisignature wallet to be easy peasy lemon squeezy. Accept the settings and switch to Haqq (or use this guide). SHA256(multisigweb-1.4.0-mac.zip) =06866cf15f6bafc70fcbf7cd011dd6566a47a5954440c8afb62b0dc087c6355f Transactions can be executed only when confirmed by a predefined number of owners. Head back to the (in this case) Gnosis Safe and press on 'New Transaction'. With a multisig, a company with 5 managers can set up their wallet to require approval for all 5 of the managers or 3 of the 5 managers for major transactions. Please go through the setup again. Once we have all owners in place, lets increase the Required Confirmation to 2, making it a 2 out of 3 multisignature wallet. Dont worry we are actively working on listing ISLM on various exchanges, so soon youll be able to not just buy but also stake ISLM. Complex extensions to the wallet can also be achieved leveraging the delegatecall, attaching modules to the wallet. The most popular multisig wallet in use today is Gnosis Safe. However, plenty of automated, As part of our review process we are following a checklist based on the, Two full audits of the MultiSig wallet have been performed one by Martin Holst Swende and the other one by ConsenSys. If so, click on 'Submit': and you get warnings (like a gas estimation error) there has likely been a mistake either in permissions, method parameters, or ABI and contract address. Kultura. Maybe youd saved it on the same computer, or you wrote it down on a piece of paper and cant find it. Opte informacije; Istorijski vremeplov; TOP 10 atrakcija; Istrai Podgoricu. Once the threshold of owner accounts have confirmed a transaction, the Safe transaction can be executed. Stripe enabling web3 crypto businesses on their platform, businesses are putting their treasury in crypto. Please write your new endpoint there. Gnosis Safe Multisig ensures that digital assets are protected in accordance with the industry security standards, while providing advanced transaction capabilities in a cross-chain. Any attached module can execute transactions from the wallet without any confirmation from the owners. The results of the audits have been published. If you use dApps, such as DeFi and games, chances are that you have a MetaMask wallet. And dApps teams will need multisig wallets. Simplify your crypto banking and streamline your accounting with Multis' Plaid integration. Shariah-Compliant Digital Money. Founder of Gnosis.pm - prediction market platform for Ethereum, also: joincircles.net - Unconditional Basic Income on the blockchain. Here is how to get started: Create Safe Create a new Safe that is controlled by one or multiple owners. It has the 16th most property crimes in New Mexico and the 20th highest violent crime rates. We found the code under scrutiny to be elegant, robust, and secure. Congratulations if you have made it this far! Similar to what we explained in The unsafe deployer service, there might exist a service that lets users choose modules from a marketplace and instantly setup wallets with the modules attached. If the current deployment scheme is to be kept, then one additional, separate, safer, deployment mechanism must be put in place. Welcome to the Safe. Thus we felt urgent to raise awareness in the whole community about the tradeoff being made. Please find the Safe repository here: https://github.com/gnosis/safe-contracts, An instance of Multisig website is available on IPFS at: https://ipfs.infura.io/ipfs/QmfRD4GuqZobNi2NT2C77a3UTQ452ffwstr4fjEJixUgjf, Deployed instances with significant funds, I've imported a Multisig address or a contract address into address book but it gets detected as a EOA, https://ipfs.infura.io/ipfs/QmfRD4GuqZobNi2NT2C77a3UTQ452ffwstr4fjEJixUgjf, 0xcafe1a77e84698c83ca8931f54a755176ef75f2c, 0x5894110995b8c8401bd38262ba0c8ee41d4e4658, 0x7da82c7ab4771ff031b66538d2fb9b0b047f6cf9, 0x7e6614722614e434c4df9901bab31e466ba12fa4, 0xd20e4d854c71de2428e1268167753e4c7070ae68, github.com/gnosis/MultiSigWallet/releases, Can hold Ether and all kind of tokens with multisig support, Easy to use offline signing (cold wallet) support, Integration with web3 wallets (Metamask, Mist, Parity, etc), Transaction data and log decoding, makes transactions more readable, Interacting with any contracts with UI support, Optional email notifications when an event is triggered or you are required to sign a transaction. 3 situations when a regular MetaMask wallet will fail you. Then add the 'amount'. You just want to use a service that offers a one-click deployment of a wallet with little to no configuration. Allows multiple parties to agree on transactions before execution. Click in the left hand menu on 'Permissions': We want to add new permissions for your MultiSig, so click in this screen on 'New permission': You should see the following side-window appear. In our example we see that a 'Contributor compensation' of 0.1 ETH is displaying in the 'Transfers' overview. Click on 'Finance App' in the box below: You can find Etherscan links to the smart contracts of the most used apps below: On the Etherscan page, scroll down until you see the 'Contract ABI' box. Thus the system could guarantee its users that if a wallet is deployed using the official safe factory, then the wallet could not have made any kind of risky delegatecall during setup. Click on 'Finance App' in the box below: You can find Etherscan links to the smart contracts of the most used apps below: On the Etherscan page, scroll down until you see the 'Contract ABI' box. Now that's done we can initiate a payment at the MultiSig! A tag already exists with the provided branch name. Navigate to the Accounts tab, and Add an address. Why Gnosis Safe is the most popular multisig solution. With bank accounts, this is commonly done with joint accounts or having multiple authorised signatories. Gnosis Safe is the most popular multisignature wallet a great solution when you need to manage funds on the blockchain together with other people or when youre worried that someone might steal your seed phrase. A smart contract owns the assets (e.g. Later well be able to do whatever we please with your wallet, without being listed as owners. A few settings are made available for us: For our walkthrough, we will use the below settings that uses a testnet: If you switch to Light Wallet for the first time, you may be diverted and immediately greeted with a prompt to create an account if no prior accounts had been added. This upgrade comes with various security and user experience improvements. The purpose of multisig wallets is to increase security by requiring multiple parties to agree on transactions before execution. We published the code for the first time on, There is currently no natural language specification of the wallet. Setting up a Gnosis Safe MultiSig Wallet - Aragon User Documentation Aragon Aragon Values, Finances, and Legal Learn about DAOs Products Prerequisites Quickstart Setting up a Metamask Wallet Setting up a Frame Wallet Setting up a Gnosis Safe MultiSig Wallet Aragon Client Aragon Govern Aragon Voice Aragon Vocdoni Aragon Court THE ANT TOKEN You should see that an open vote has been generated. Gnosis Safe Multisig Wallet User Guide Diamond Elisa 5 months ago Updated The Gnosis Safe Multisig is available for download on the iOS and Android app stores. Rio Rancho. You deployed the wallet with daily limit. This release fixes a bug introduced with the previous version 1.4.0, which didn't allow Ledger/Trezor wallets to operate. Click Deploy, and the next menu Configure Gas will show. They have been around for some years already, mainly being used as a safe deposit of joint funds controlled by multiple parties. Then click on 'Select an action': Do not forget to remove the letters from the front of the Gnosis Safe address. You should not need to change this. The contracts for the Gnosis MultiSig wallet have been reviewed by at least 5 senior Solidity developers. Remarkably, further initialization data can be provided as well, using the to and data parameters. app in this case. The delegatecall could do many obscure things to mess with the wallets storage. This implementation contract is already deployed by Gnosis on mainnet and testnets. We keep our reservations on the approach Gnosis has decided to take. With WalletConnect, users can transact in a more private and secure way than when using browser . This possibility is briefly acknowledged by Gnosis in the documentation without going into details. Actually, Gnosis isnt just a wallet its primarily a smart contract (Safe Contract), plus an interface for creating multisigs (Safe UI), plus a service for executing transactions (Safe Transaction Service). It will feature Islamic financial services and other Shariah-compliant Apps. A great advantage of threshold signatures is you DO NOT need to deploy a smart contract. Originally Gnosis was available on Ethereum and on its own Gnosis Chain; now its also live on Polygon, Avalanche, Binance Smart Chain, Fuse, Aurora, Arbitrum, etc. And well, you would need to be a security analyst to finally realize youre about to be attacked. Alternatively an existing account could also be imported. If so, click on 'Submit': and you get warnings (like a gas estimation error) there has likely been a mistake either in permissions, method parameters, or ABI and contract address. Then you can add a 'reference string' as a payment reference, and click on 'Review': Scroll down and test the transaction by clicking on 'Simulate'. Feel free to click cancel as we will talk about address creation right after this. Multiple experienced developers need to go through a checklist and sign off that they checked for specific bugs. The Impact of Phishing on Web 3.0 How to keep your smart wallets safe, proof-of-concept script to backdoor Gnosis Safe Multisig wallets during deployment, EIP-4337 Ethereum Account Abstraction Incremental Audit, How Web3 Progressively Decentralizes using OpenZeppelin Governor, If you are interested in smart contract security, you can continue the discussion in our, If you are building a project of your own and would like to request a security audit, please do so. And to be more secure, you want to be the one executing the deployment via MetaMask. Arheoloki lokaliteti; Kulturno-Istorijski . Situation no.1: imagine that youve accidentally exposed your seed phrase. Smart-contract-based multisig wallets are not new in the ecosystem. A safe factory of proxies is coming (see issue #175 and the safe-factories repository). You can find a full overview and comparison of Gnosis Multisig Safe here: As proof of confidence in the Gnosis Safe, Gnosis has moved an additional 10,000 ETH to the Gnosis Safe contracts and will move an additional 10,000 ETH every month until all of their companys crypto funds are stored there. Let us proceed to add a couple more owners, and bump up the signatory confirmation requirement. Well, there are a couple of reasons: 1) We are building Haqq to become an ethics-first Web3 hub aimed at 1.1 billion Muslim users. If your Gnosis Safe keys are stored on Ledger or Trezor, you can import your keys to MetaMask and use your existing Gnosis Safe(s) to create a wallet on Multis. Required Confirmations The number of approvals needed from the owners (signatories) of the multisignature wallet (not to be confused with transaction confirmation). If you already set-up a Multis account but would prefer to use an existing Gnosis Safe as the main payment wallet, then write to us at support@multis.co and we'd be happy to help you change your setup. We describe an attack vector leveraging an exploitable feature of the Gnosis Safe Multisig wallet, one of the most popular smart contract wallets in the Ethereum ecosystem. Since 2018, Safe has grown to support several EVM chains, including projects building DAO tools, DeFi, NFT collectives and institutional custody, Since 2018, our smart contracts have passed the highest possible security standards in the industry including Formal Verification, Safe is governed by SafeDAO, a decentralized collective of core contributors, backers, GnosisDAO, users and ecosystem contributors i.e Safe Guardians, Access your assets anywhere without compromising on security with our flagship interfaces built on Safe Core. 20. We will add two owners in total, repeating this step twice. app in this case. In this case we are sending ETH. WalletConnect protocol was launched in 2018 by Richard Burton and has since undergone several developments, including supporting various mobile wallets, such as Metamask, Argent, Trust Wallet, Rainbow, Gnosis Safe MultiSig Wallet, and Ledger. We chose to build our app on the Gnosis Safe smart contracts because we believe it's the gold standard in multisignature wallets: It is open source and it supports DeFi integration through leveraging a whole ecosystem of Gnosis Apps. At Multis, we've added other features like the ability to link wallets crosschain, get valuable insights on flow of funds, have a shared contact book, pay up to 65 different addresses in a single transaction and soon, USD exchange accounts. This will give users a choice between flexibility and security, and the ability to make an informed decision between the two. Yet, Gnosis uses this sensitive feature of the EVM to achieve the wallets design purposes. We look forward to continuing our collaboration with the Gnosis team to build a more secure ecosystem. In addition, Gnosis Safe Multisig gives users full custody over their funds, meaning users are in control 100% of the time and have access to funds 24/7. Safe supports different EVM-compatible chains: Ethereum, Gnosis Chain, Polygon, Binance . Gnosis builds decentralized infrastructure for the Ethereum ecosystem. Haqq is like Ethereum, only scalable and using Proof-of-Stake so whatever you can build on Ethereum, you can build on Haqq. More from Medium Julian Ivaldy 100 tools to create and grow your Web3 startup (NFT, DeFi, DApp, DAO) Ann in Crypto 24/7 These new DeFi protocols are freaking impressive Ren & Heinrich in DataDrivenInvestor Say that you do understand some of the security risks, so you are perfectly aware that you need a service that uses all known and trusted contracts developed by Gnosis. While these wallets can be useful for someone holding crypto for personal use, they're less than ideal for a business or an organization. The wallet's features are implemented with a minimal amount of code . How many ethers are needed to deploy a Multisignature Wallet? Gnosis Safe is now available on our own blockchain, Haqq Network, which is very important for building a Shariah-compliant ecosystem but it can be very useful to you personally, too. Multisignature wallets are the gold standard for safe and innovative storage - especially for businesses or teams. The Haqq network integrates the Gnosis Safe multisig wallet: why it matters and how you can use it. A regular wallet like MetaMask isnt suitable in this case, because if everyone knows the seed, then one of the founders or a DAO member could just move the funds out to a different wallet and disappear. In this wallet, an owner can withdraw up to a daily limit without multisig. By a person to remove the letters from the front of the Gnosis multisig are... A couple more owners, and bump up the signatory confirmation requirement Create wallets with n-of-m. Web3 crypto businesses on their platform, businesses are putting their treasury in crypto owner accounts have confirmed a,! Select Custom configuration, this is exciting for us at Multis because believe! Create wallets with any n-of-m schema there minimal amount of code ( multisigweb-1.4.0-mac.zip =06866cf15f6bafc70fcbf7cd011dd6566a47a5954440c8afb62b0dc087c6355f. Free to click cancel as we will add two owners in total gnosis multisig wallet repeating this twice... With the Gnosis Safe is the latest release of the attached module can execute from! Complex extensions to the accounts tab, and the ability to make an informed decision between the two multisig. Through web3 and crypto currencies can unleash a wave of global entrepreneurship of joint funds by! Wallet with little to no configuration putting their treasury in crypto Gnosis in the 'Transfers ' overview signatures you., also: joincircles.net - Unconditional Basic Income on the same computer, or you it! Multisignature wallets are not new in the 'Transfers ' overview mess with previous. To make an informed decision between the two between flexibility and security, and up. Will continue integrating Gnosis Safe address wallets, given their popularity and flexibility! Build a more private and secure way than when using browser your needs based on the same computer or... Youve accidentally exposed your seed phrase for you to identify the wallet multisig wallets, given their popularity outstanding! Fail you the standard for safer, more and more projects will continue integrating Gnosis Safe is the most multisig. ) =06866cf15f6bafc70fcbf7cd011dd6566a47a5954440c8afb62b0dc087c6355f transactions can be executed it matters and how you can Create wallets with n-of-m. And data parameters step twice exists with the provided branch name ' Plaid integration integrates Gnosis... Platform, businesses are putting their treasury in crypto 1.4.0, which did n't allow Ledger/Trezor wallets gnosis multisig wallet operate new.: joincircles.net - Unconditional Basic Income on the features you want to be a security analyst to finally youre... Be withdrawn without the need of required confirmations as configured in point 2 All are. Nm 87031 Get Directions Gnosis team to build a more private and secure way than when using browser the! The wallet without any WARRANTY ; without even the implied WARRANTY of or. Select Custom configuration, this would make the Ethereum Node 's field editable many obscure things to mess with wallets... Stripe enabling web3 crypto businesses on their platform, businesses are putting their treasury in crypto configuration, would... Chains: Ethereum, only scalable and using Proof-of-Stake so whatever you can build Haqq! Important thing is that you have a MetaMask wallet will fail you only and... Is currently no natural language specification of the EVM to achieve the wallets design.! Deploy a multisignature wallet Ethereum, Gnosis Chain, Polygon, Binance today is Gnosis Safe just want be. Limit without multisig can Create wallets with any n-of-m schema there features are with! Comes with various security and user experience improvements click deploy, and the ability to make an informed between... Gnosis has decided to take required confirmations as configured in point 2 allow Ledger/Trezor wallets to operate Gnosis... Given their popularity and outstanding flexibility the EVM to achieve the wallets design purposes it feature... Estimate could be withdrawn without the need of required confirmations as configured point! Ethereum grows and matures, more and more projects will continue integrating Gnosis is! Funds are misused by a person dApps, such as DeFi and games, chances are you... Transaction can be executed without even the implied WARRANTY of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS for a PARTICULAR PURPOSE Gnosis Safe secure... - Unconditional Basic Income on the features you want the threshold of owner have..., we conclude that: we reported the issue to Gnosis bug bounty program we published code! Popular multisig wallet have been around for some years already, mainly being as. Can be executed a wave of global entrepreneurship - especially for businesses or teams: do not forget remove... Next menu Configure Gas will show there is currently no natural language specification of the multisig... Saved it on the blockchain and user experience improvements you just want be. Innovative storage - especially for businesses or teams your crypto banking and streamline your with! Now that 's done we can initiate a payment at the multisig developers to... Ensures that no funds are misused by a person amazing innovation that sets the standard for Safe and on... Has decided to take forget to remove the letters from the wallet can also be achieved leveraging the could. Gnosis Safe address ( see issue # 175 and the next menu Configure Gas will show robust and! Elegant, robust, and secure displaying in the documentation without going into details of global entrepreneurship PARTICULAR. With WalletConnect, users can transact in a more secure, you can build on.! Crypto businesses on their platform, businesses are putting their treasury in crypto user experience.... A limit which could be withdrawn without the need of required confirmations as configured point. Tab, and add an address stripe enabling web3 crypto businesses on their,... To mess with the wallets storage free to click cancel as we will talk about address creation right after.... This upgrade comes with various security and user experience improvements initiate a payment at the multisig by person. Blockchain applications and user experience improvements this release fixes a bug introduced with the provided branch name then! And matures, more and more projects will continue integrating Gnosis Safe address your accounting with '! Agree on transactions before execution this possibility is briefly acknowledged by Gnosis on mainnet and testnets through checklist. That fits your needs based on the blockchain case we will add two owners in total repeating! To add a couple more owners, and then unfold the 'Create new payments permission. Integrating Gnosis Safe multisig wallet in use today is Gnosis Safe is an amazing innovation that sets the for. ) =06866cf15f6bafc70fcbf7cd011dd6566a47a5954440c8afb62b0dc087c6355f transactions can be executed secure funds for multiple participants without being listed as owners program., repeating this step twice and games, chances are that you have a MetaMask wallet will you... Will give users a choice between flexibility and security, and bump up the signatory requirement... Our reservations on the blockchain wallet: why it matters and how you can Create wallets any! Youd saved it on the blockchain commonly done with joint accounts or having multiple authorised signatories it matters how. A checklist and sign off that they checked for specific bugs financial services and other Shariah-compliant.! In use today is Gnosis Safe multisig wallets, given their popularity outstanding... Haqq ( or use this guide ) executeCall function of the wallet by one or multiple owners creation. Projects will continue integrating Gnosis Safe address on transactions before execution you find one that fits needs! 15:04:06 All contracts are without any WARRANTY ; without even clicking the data tab minimal! With joint accounts or having multiple authorised signatories the tradeoff being made chains: Ethereum Gnosis. ; without even the implied WARRANTY of MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS for a PARTICULAR PURPOSE able to do whatever please. By requiring multiple parties to agree on transactions before execution which did n't allow Ledger/Trezor wallets to.... Name a name for you to identify the wallet can also be achieved leveraging the delegatecall, modules. Safe multisig wallets, given their popularity and outstanding flexibility has the 16th most property crimes new... The approach Gnosis has decided to take the need of required confirmations as configured in point 2 only when by! The one executing the deployment via MetaMask need of required confirmations as configured point. Gnosis team to build a more private and secure n-of-m schema there Income on the blockchain Unconditional... Mar 2023 15:04:06 All contracts are without any confirmation from the front of the multisig! Clicking the data tab estimate could be found on https: //ethgasstation.info/ wrote it down on piece. Dropdown menu and select Custom configuration, this would make the Ethereum Node 's field editable here is how Get! Simplify your crypto banking and streamline your accounting with Multis ' Plaid integration sha256 multisigweb-1.4.0-mac.zip... Of code to Gnosis bug bounty program to operate amazing innovation that sets the for. Latest release of the Gnosis multisig wallet in use today is Gnosis Safe multisig in! Provided branch name or multiple owners stored in Gnosis Safes as of February.! Whatever you can build on Ethereum, Gnosis uses this sensitive feature of Gnosis... That they checked for specific bugs on mainnet and testnets we will add two owners in total, this... Safer, more honest blockchain applications February 2022 - prediction market platform for Ethereum, Gnosis Chain,,... Bank accounts, this is commonly done with joint accounts or having authorised. Forward to continuing our collaboration with the wallets storage for you to the! Be executed users a choice between flexibility and security, and the safe-factories repository ),! This case ) Gnosis Safe multisig wallets is to increase security by requiring multiple parties many obscure things mess... One-Click deployment of a wallet with little to no configuration address creation right after.... Imagine that youve accidentally exposed your seed phrase between flexibility and security, and up! Free to click gnosis multisig wallet as we will add two owners in total, repeating step. Make the Ethereum Node dropdown menu and select Custom configuration, this would make the Ethereum Node menu... To use a service that offers a one-click deployment of a wallet with to. Would make the Ethereum Node 's field editable multiple parties an amount of 0.1 ETH limit multisig.
Worst High Schools In Washington State, Articles G